As a follow-up to the post by Rod Dickens (”Can’t Always Judge a Book by its Cover”), I feel compelled to also offer my perspective, since I was the editor who traveled to Kearney, MO, to visit the contractor and shoot the image for PRO’s Summer 2009 cover.
Let me start by making one thing clear: The three contractors who took exception to the cover did so because they are very passionate about this business. That is honorable. Everybody wants an even playing field where all contractors are insured and certified, employ legal workers, drive clean trucks, operate commercial-grade equipment, look like professionals, perform the work like professionals, and charge a fair market price for that work. Regretfully, that day has yet to arrive. And unfortunately, the reasons why go way beyond something as simple as “mowing in a sweatshirt.”
But let’s talk about personal appearance, since that was the bone of contention with respect to our Summer cover. As a contractor and business owner, you’ve put your livelihood on the line and invested tens if not hundreds of thousands of dollars of your own money in trucks and equipment. That said, whose right is it to tell you what you have to wear to work in order to refer to yourself as a professional?
At the same time, thousands of other contractors have taken similar risks and made similar investments, and they’re pretty adamant that uniformed crews are essential to projecting a more professional image of this industry. It’s not fair to them when a segment of the industry continues to harm that image.
So … who decides what is and is not professional? Do regional and national associations that represent only a small percentage of all established landscape companies in the U.S. issue a decree? Does the biggest, baddest landscape company in a given market set the tone for that market? Conversely, is it the fly-by-night trunk slammer who shows up to mow in a Metallica tank-top? Should Nancy Pelosi and Barney Frank get involved?
Here’s an idea: The customer is the decider. In the case of the contractor on our Summer cover, he specializes in commercial and high-end residential maintenance. Because of his reputation and the professional “behavior” of his crews, the movers and shakers in his small market have sought him out to maintain their properties. He’s enjoyed a 95% customer retention rate for years.
If you look on page 8 of that same Summer issue, you’ll see that this contractor does have company shirts, because he’s wearing one himself. It got a bit rainy and chilly the day I was in town to shoot the cover photo, so the mower operators had thrown on sweatshirts. The bottom line is that the owner of the property they were mowing could care less, because when the crew finished up and drove off, that property was the crown jewel of the neighborhood.
Perhaps the issue isn’t whether or not it’s OK for a landscape professional to be mowing in a sweatshirt. Maybe the issue is simply PRO Magazine showing that on a cover. I promise you, we’ll be much more conscientious in the future.
Case in point, a week after we’d received those two emails about the Summer cover, I headed out to hang with a local landscaper who was installing a retaining wall and staircase in the backyard of a duplex. As I was shooting pictures, thinking that down the road we may want to use one on a cover of PRO, I asked the contractor, John Martin of Lawn Enforcement, if he had a company shirt he could throw on over the dusty, sweaty gray T-shirt he’d been wearing all day.
John looked down at the ground for a second before responding. “Actually, I don’t,” he said softly. “But I do have a jacket with my company logo that I wear in the off-season to help advertise. I could run home and bring that back after lunch.”
I thought about how John responded to me, willing to do whatever he could to accommodate my request. I thought about how considerate and honest he is, and how much his customers appreciate that. I looked at the gorgeous project that was unfolding before my eyes. I looked at the wedding ring on his left hand, remembering that he has a wife and young daughter he provides for by being a professional landscape contractor with not a single unethical bone in his body.
“No dude,” I responded. “It’s really humid today. Forget the jacket, because you’re doing just fine.”
~ Gregg Wartgow, PRO editor-in-chief